• Health
  • Research

Know-It-Alls More Likely To Accept Falsehoods as Fact, Study Shows

2 minute read

People who consider themselves experts in a given topic are more likely to claim knowledge of made-up “facts” about that topic, a new study shows.

Researchers conducted a series of experiments to assess how likely people were to believe fictions presented as fact. In one of the experiments, for example, the researchers had 100 people rate their level of knowledge for personal finance by describing their familiarity with 15 different financial terms.

What the participants didn’t know was that some of the terms were fake. For instance, the researchers used made-up words like “pre-rated stocks”, “fixed-rate deduction”, and “annualized credit.” They found that the people who claimed they were personal finance experts were more likely to identify the fake words as genuine financial jargon. The researchers conducted similar tests for other topics and discovered similar results.

“The more people believed they knew about finances in general, the more likely they were to overclaim knowledge of the fictitious financial terms,” said study author Stav Atir, a psychological scientist at Cornell University in a statement. “The same pattern emerged for other domains, including biology, literature, philosophy, and geography.”

The researchers argue that the findings, which are published in the journal Psychological Science, indicate failures among people to acknowledge gaps in their own expertise. The authors suggest that people may be less willing to educate themselves about topics they think they know everything about, even when they should.

See The Best Biology Photos Of The Year

Two Bisons on the Grand Prismatic Spring in Yellowstone National Park, Wyo.
Two Bisons on the Grand Prismatic Spring in Yellowstone National Park, Wyo.Lukas Gawenda
A spider at sunset in Predel, Bulgaria.
A spider at sunset in Predel, Bulgaria.Krasimir Matarov
Parental care in parasitoid wasps
Parasitoid wasps building clay pots in Borneo, Brunei.Thomas Endlein
Siblings watering newly planted seedlings in Rizal, The Philippines.
Siblings watering newly planted seedlings in Rizal, The Philippines.Ysabel M Victoriano
A leopard in its natural habitat in Karantaka, India.
A leopard in its natural habitat in Karantaka, India.Nagarjun Ram
A farmer protects his family and animals from mosquitos in Gujarat, India.
A farmer protects his family and animals from mosquitos in Gujarat, India.Dimple Pancholi
A tarsier in its natural habitat in Sulawesi, Indonesia.
A tarsier in its natural habitat in Sulawesi, Indonesia.Wolfgang Weinhardt
A plant takes advantage of the available shelter in a dilapidated house in Kolmanskop, Namibia.
A plant takes advantage of the available shelter in a dilapidated house in Kolmanskop, Namibia.Kelsey Green
A female blackbird holding a dried mealworm in her mouth in Lincolnshire, United Kingdom.
A female blackbird holding a dried mealworm in her mouth in Lincolnshire, United Kingdom.Billy Clapham
A chick embryo in a hardened eggshell is sustained until full development in Rizal, The Philippines.Robert Cabagnot
An adult female Italian crested newt stationed below the fresh water surface in Piedmont, Italy.
An adult female Italian crested newt stationed below the fresh water surface in Piedmont, Italy.Matteo Riccardo Di Nicola
A sea turtle eating a jellyfish in The Maldives.
A sea turtle eating a jellyfish in The Maldives.Boris Barath

More Must-Reads From TIME

Contact us at letters@time.com